Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

LetMyPeopleVote

(166,448 posts)
6. Supreme Court rules Trump administration must give Venezuelans more time to challenge deportation under Alien Enemies Ac
Fri May 16, 2025, 04:25 PM
May 16

This also makes me smile. 24 hours is not sufficient time to object
Venezuelan men held in Texas had urged the court to prevent the government from sending them to a prison in El Salvador before they could challenge the move in court.

BREAKING: Supreme Court rules Trump administration must give Venezuelans more time to challenge deportation under Alien Enemies Act

www.nbcnews.com/politics/sup...

MSNBC (@msnbc.com) 2025-05-16T20:15:44.657Z



https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/supreme-court/supreme-court-trump-administration-venezuelans-alien-enemies-act-rcna202094

WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court on Friday dealt a blow against the Trump administration's attempt to send Venezuelans it says are gang members to a notorious prison in El Salvador, saying the detainees must have a proper chance to raise legal objections.

The 7-2 decision, which grants a request made by a group of Venezuelans, clarified an unusual order issued by the justices in the early hours of April 19 that hit pause on any government plans to deport people held in northern Texas.

The justices in the latest unsigned decision faulted the administration for only giving the detainees 24 hours to launch legal challenges.

"Under these circumstances, notice roughly 24 hours before removal, devoid of information about how to exercise due process rights to contest that removal, surely does not pass muster," the ruling said......

The Trump administration's attempt to summarily deport immigrants without giving them a chance to contest whether they are gang members or whether the law can even be applied to criminal organizations is part of its hardline immigration policy that has faced considerable pushback from courts as well as political opponents.

Although the Alien Enemies Act can only be used at a time of "invasions or predatory incursions," the government has argued that those conditions are met because the gang is effectively an arm of the Venezuelan government, a claim that is heavily contested.

The court's April order, coming just hours after a bus carrying Venezuelans left a detention center in Texas toward an airport but then turned around, put the entire case on hold while the justices figured out what next steps to take.

The Supreme Court had, in an April 7 decision, made it clear that any people the government wants to deport under the Alien Enemies Act need to be given the chance to challenge the decision via habeas corpus petitions.

Recommendations

9 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Trump doesn't care? Irish_Dem May 16 #1
Of course not sakabatou May 16 #2
He's BeerBarrelPolka May 16 #30
Maybe he can get the DOJ to arrest one of the SC judges. Irish_Dem May 16 #35
Amy Coney Barrett BeerBarrelPolka May 16 #36
Oh yes she is the one they would go after. Irish_Dem May 16 #38
Trump: "How many divisions does the Supreme Court have?" tblue37 May 17 #42
But that is part of the problem, isn't it? OldBaldy1701E May 17 #44
Time BeerBarrelPolka May 17 #45
Looks like he cared after all 0rganism May 16 #37
Supreme Court blocks Trump from restarting Alien Enemies Act deportations LetMyPeopleVote May 16 #3
Bring them back now and allow due process if they can prove their offenses are unlawful. Deuxcents May 16 #4
Meanwhile, House Republicans blocked Trump's spending bill today BoRaGard May 16 #5
Ketchup bottles be a-flyin' tonight! 😁 ShazzieB May 16 #16
Supreme Court rules Trump administration must give Venezuelans more time to challenge deportation under Alien Enemies Ac LetMyPeopleVote May 16 #6
+1 dalton99a May 16 #10
OK maybe I'll start hoping again. I was expecting them to sell us all up the river. And democracy. lindysalsagal May 16 #7
When you kidnap someone isn't that breaking the law ? Beachnutt May 16 #8
Good but who will enforce bringing them back? Meowmee May 16 #9
just exactly what I have been wondering for months rurallib May 16 #11
Yes, but the media will continue to pretend it isn't Meowmee May 16 #12
It will be up to the American citizenry then.... hadEnuf May 16 #14
They're still being held in the Northern District of Texas. sl8 May 16 #29
Executive branch (president) enforces the laws and rulings IronLionZion May 16 #32
Yes I know all of that Meowmee May 16 #34
Next, take away the immunity and write orders for his arrest. Clouds Passing May 16 #13
Congratulations, Supreme Court ReRe May 16 #15
It was so obvious, but with this Court, you never know. surfered May 16 #17
He would have been in charge of the show trials. Iggo May 16 #33
K&R for, umkay one small step... UTUSN May 16 #18
Is that all Iamscrewed May 16 #19
Newsflash: Trump plans on violating B.See May 16 #20
and SCOTUS will get pissed and continue to vote against him in every case LymphocyteLover May 16 #21
right... B.See May 16 #24
it's happening.... big question is whether they actually attack SCOTUS more directly LymphocyteLover May 18 #50
didn't have to wait long... B.See May 24 #51
So, with THIS ruling, if i read it right. That not just one person (Garcia) but ALL bluestarone May 16 #22
This case is about the Venezuelan detainees being held in the Northern District of Texas, not Garcia. nt sl8 May 16 #25
Ah, my bad bluestarone May 16 #26
The issue isn't how SCOTUS rules EnergizedLib May 16 #23
If you can stomach it, read Sam the Flim-Flam man's dissent maxrandb May 16 #27
"The issue isn't how SCOTUS rules. It's if these rulings will be complied with." J_William_Ryan May 16 #28
Alito and Thomas show utter contempt for the constitution Mysterian May 16 #31
They're the two dumbest white men on the court mdbl May 17 #46
Thanks for the link to the order. TomSlick May 16 #39
I've got your deportation order RIGHT HERE usonian May 16 #40
TSF: "They made their decision... Wednesdays May 16 #41
Well, that's according to Horace Greeley. sl8 May 17 #43
So What? Dave Id May 17 #47
That's very important, but a different case. sl8 May 17 #48
Will the deported Supremes have private cells in Libya or El Salvador? Ping Tung May 17 #49
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»BREAKING: The Supreme Cou...»Reply #6