Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

FBaggins

(28,514 posts)

20. Some corrections

Reply to hlthe2b (Reply #16)

Wed Oct 22, 2025, 09:49 AM

Wednesday

The 9th is a little different. Their en banc panel is the chief plus ten randomly selected judges. They never do the entire panel (though all 29 can vote on whether to hear an appeal en banc or not)

I don’t think it was Immergut who requested review… but rather one of the other circuit judges (not on the ruling panel). It isn’t common, but it is by no means unprecedented, for an off-panel judge to request en-banc review.

Note that they still haven’t decided whether or not to rehear the Newsom v Trump case that this ruling relied upon. It’s been over four months

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

hlthe2b

20 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

I thought that the 9th Court of appeal is liberal.. [View all] question everything Tuesday OP

Same one ITAL Tuesday #1

2 of the 3 Judge Panel were TSF Appointees Nictuku Tuesday #2

Fuck THAT!!! AZJonnie Tuesday #3

10 of the 29 judges (excluding the senior status judges) are Trump appointees. RockRaven Tuesday #4

Thanks, RR. People don't keep up. The Courts change slowly, but they do change, and the 9th Circuit... Hekate Tuesday #8

But at least our powder is dry while trump stuffs dozens more lifetime appointments down our throats via the nuclear... Hassin Bin Sober Tuesday #10

Huh? Harry Reid went nuclear in 2013 and ended judicial filibusters. tritsofme Tuesday #11

Yes Hekate Tuesday #14

We are in the minority in Congress. In the Senate Mitch McConnell made some kind of deal w the Devil... Hekate Tuesday #13

Harry Reid changed the rules for all non-Supreme Court federal judges in 2013 Polybius Wednesday #18

Nixon? Polybius Wednesday #17

Here are the 3 Nixon judges who are still alive and have Senior status: Celerity Wednesday #19

It is an it isn't FBaggins Tuesday #5

See right below. Only 10 of the 29 are trump appointees. ancianita Tuesday #7

While it's "only" 10, the 10 shouldn't be minimized. That 10 makes a difference. In It to Win It Tuesday #15

Depends maybe on who the judges were who ruled. 10 were from trump. Here are their names in order of seniority. ancianita Tuesday #6

Not at all a done deal dpibel Tuesday #9

It was more liberal until Trump got elected in 2016. Trump appointed 10 out of the 29 active judges on the 9th Circuit In It to Win It Tuesday #12

They are going to have to rehear the case en banc (entire 9th panel) hlthe2b Wednesday #16

Some corrections FBaggins Wednesday #20