General Discussion

maxrandb

(16,682 posts)

27. If you can stomach it, read Sam the Flim-Flam man's dissent

Reply to In It to Win It (Original post)

Fri May 16, 2025, 06:22 PM

May 16

Last edited Sat May 17, 2025, 06:01 AM - Edit history (1)

I am not a lawyer, but he seems to be saying "what's the big deal in days, weeks, months, or years of appellate review?."

It's not like they were about to be renditioned to a Salvadoran Death Camp for life...except that they were!!!!!!

It's like saying I am going to wait on cancer treatment, because it hasn't killed me yet.

I am so fucking sick of these pompous pricks pretending that their rulings HAVE NO REAL WORLD AFFECT.

You don't fucking call it a "ball, or strike" when the batters been beaned in the fucking face.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Wednesdays

51 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

BREAKING: The Supreme Court holds that the Trump administration violated the due process rights of Venezuelan migrants [View all] In It to Win It May 16 OP

Trump doesn't care? Irish_Dem May 16 #1

Of course not sakabatou May 16 #2

He's BeerBarrelPolka May 16 #30

Maybe he can get the DOJ to arrest one of the SC judges. Irish_Dem May 16 #35

Amy Coney Barrett BeerBarrelPolka May 16 #36

Oh yes she is the one they would go after. Irish_Dem May 16 #38

Trump: "How many divisions does the Supreme Court have?" tblue37 May 17 #42

But that is part of the problem, isn't it? OldBaldy1701E May 17 #44

Time BeerBarrelPolka May 17 #45

Looks like he cared after all 0rganism May 16 #37

Supreme Court blocks Trump from restarting Alien Enemies Act deportations LetMyPeopleVote May 16 #3

Bring them back now and allow due process if they can prove their offenses are unlawful. Deuxcents May 16 #4

Meanwhile, House Republicans blocked Trump's spending bill today BoRaGard May 16 #5

Ketchup bottles be a-flyin' tonight! 😁 ShazzieB May 16 #16

Supreme Court rules Trump administration must give Venezuelans more time to challenge deportation under Alien Enemies Ac LetMyPeopleVote May 16 #6

+1 dalton99a May 16 #10

OK maybe I'll start hoping again. I was expecting them to sell us all up the river. And democracy. lindysalsagal May 16 #7

When you kidnap someone isn't that breaking the law ? Beachnutt May 16 #8

Good but who will enforce bringing them back? Meowmee May 16 #9

just exactly what I have been wondering for months rurallib May 16 #11

Yes, but the media will continue to pretend it isn't Meowmee May 16 #12

It will be up to the American citizenry then.... hadEnuf May 16 #14

They're still being held in the Northern District of Texas. sl8 May 16 #29

Executive branch (president) enforces the laws and rulings IronLionZion May 16 #32

Yes I know all of that Meowmee May 16 #34

Next, take away the immunity and write orders for his arrest. Clouds Passing May 16 #13

Congratulations, Supreme Court ReRe May 16 #15

It was so obvious, but with this Court, you never know. surfered May 16 #17

He would have been in charge of the show trials. Iggo May 16 #33

K&R for, umkay one small step... UTUSN May 16 #18

Is that all Iamscrewed May 16 #19

Newsflash: Trump plans on violating B.See May 16 #20

and SCOTUS will get pissed and continue to vote against him in every case LymphocyteLover May 16 #21

right... B.See May 16 #24

it's happening.... big question is whether they actually attack SCOTUS more directly LymphocyteLover May 18 #50

didn't have to wait long... B.See May 24 #51

So, with THIS ruling, if i read it right. That not just one person (Garcia) but ALL bluestarone May 16 #22

This case is about the Venezuelan detainees being held in the Northern District of Texas, not Garcia. nt sl8 May 16 #25

Ah, my bad bluestarone May 16 #26

The issue isn't how SCOTUS rules EnergizedLib May 16 #23

If you can stomach it, read Sam the Flim-Flam man's dissent maxrandb May 16 #27

"The issue isn't how SCOTUS rules. It's if these rulings will be complied with." J_William_Ryan May 16 #28

Alito and Thomas show utter contempt for the constitution Mysterian May 16 #31

They're the two dumbest white men on the court mdbl May 17 #46

Thanks for the link to the order. TomSlick May 16 #39

I've got your deportation order RIGHT HERE usonian May 16 #40

TSF: "They made their decision... Wednesdays May 16 #41

Well, that's according to Horace Greeley. sl8 May 17 #43

So What? Dave Id May 17 #47

That's very important, but a different case. sl8 May 17 #48

Will the deported Supremes have private cells in Libya or El Salvador? Ping Tung May 17 #49