Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

senseandsensibility

(22,217 posts)
Mon May 26, 2025, 02:24 PM Monday

This is probably my most "conservative" opinion

I have never been accused of being a conservative or even a DINO. My philosophy may even be to the left of Bernie Sanders and AOC, and it is certainly to the left of many posters here.

Nevertheless, I will take a deep breath a say this: Memorial Day is about the Americans who gave their lives to give us the freedoms we enjoy.
The point of Memorial Day is to honor them. And I do honor them. In fact, I revere them, as corny as it sounds.

I am flying my flag today proudly in their honor to thank them. I don't criticize those who choose to fly it upside down however. That is their right, just one of the many that brave soldiers died to protect.

37 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
This is probably my most "conservative" opinion (Original Post) senseandsensibility Monday OP
That is neither a 'conservative' nor a 'progressive' stance, it is simply a correct one. Nation states often have their Celerity Monday #1
I wholeheartedly agree with all you say. dchill Monday #2
Why Is That Conservative? ProfessorGAC Monday #3
No senseandsensibility Monday #4
Good Plan ProfessorGAC Monday #7
I cannot see how repukes in ANY way honor our troops Skittles Monday #32
The greatest sacrifice of all awaits our men and women in uniform. Frasier Balzov Monday #5
I grok. ananda Monday #6
Fly it! Ksout Monday #8
Welcome to DU senseandsensibility Monday #9
Thank you for this heartfelt post Grim Chieftain Monday #10
Welcome to DU senseandsensibility Monday #11
Thanks for the welcome! Grim Chieftain Monday #12
Well said ..those who died should be remembered JT45242 Monday #13
Thank you Ksout Monday #14
You should post more senseandsensibility Monday #28
My Grandfather served in WW1 IbogaProject Monday #15
I think having the experience of relatives who fought in WW1 or senseandsensibility Monday #17
I honor their military service and their personal sacrifice. sop Monday #16
American progressives and conservatives alike stand under the umbrella of Ol Janx Spirit Monday #18
Very eloquent senseandsensibility Monday #19
Google disagrees TnDem Monday #20
? senseandsensibility Monday #23
OK, and what would that be? TnDem Monday #24
That sentiment is not conservative, it is proof of your humanity and good heart. LoisB Monday #21
You're right senseandsensibility Monday #25
You are absolutely correct. I never understood how they got to define themselves as the LoisB Monday #26
Democrats do not tend to use soldiers as political props Skittles Monday #33
Thank you, you are not alone! ZDU Monday #22
I can understand that as the right has been trying to say they are the patriots for a long time. Eko Monday #27
Conservative? Cirsium Monday #29
YOU GOT THAT RIGHT Skittles Tuesday #34
The teDUMP brand of patriotism is nauseating. magicarpet Monday #30
Call it the cynic in me... WarGamer Monday #31
We honor those who sacrificed, even needlessly Martin Eden Tuesday #35
I'm quite the cynic... WarGamer Tuesday #36
From D-Day to VE day was 10+ months Martin Eden Tuesday #37

Celerity

(50,032 posts)
1. That is neither a 'conservative' nor a 'progressive' stance, it is simply a correct one. Nation states often have their
Mon May 26, 2025, 02:32 PM
Monday

people die in the defence of said nation states. I honour those sacrifices.

senseandsensibility

(22,217 posts)
4. No
Mon May 26, 2025, 02:38 PM
Monday

I hope not and I agree that there is a danger of sliding into that mentality so I am going to change my OP to put conservative in quotes. That's the way I intended it, but it was probably too subtle.

Frasier Balzov

(4,391 posts)
5. The greatest sacrifice of all awaits our men and women in uniform.
Mon May 26, 2025, 02:41 PM
Monday

A decision point I will call follow or replace.

Ksout

(13 posts)
8. Fly it!
Mon May 26, 2025, 03:03 PM
Monday

Being patriotic to the country belongs neither exclusively to the right or left. The armed forces are the same way.zHowever with the 4th of July coming up , I do have trouble with the hypocrisy of those whose loyalty is now to a dictator rather to the their democracy that independence was fought for. I am a veteran.

JT45242

(3,350 posts)
13. Well said ..those who died should be remembered
Mon May 26, 2025, 03:29 PM
Monday

They fought fascists.

They fought a threat from the Chinese in korea (perceived or real...they fought for democracy)

They showed us the folly of sending poor kids to fight a war for rich people interests from France and the US in Vietnam.

They died all over the Middle East trying to protect our country even if leadership was not targeting the real power and money behind the threats.

It's not a partisan thing.

Ksout

(13 posts)
14. Thank you
Mon May 26, 2025, 03:31 PM
Monday

I, also, am a "long-time lurker". I rarely comment, but check-in almost daily to maintain my mental health with Trump's constantly disturbing my peace!

senseandsensibility

(22,217 posts)
28. You should post more
Mon May 26, 2025, 05:25 PM
Monday

The more you post the easier it gets! But I understand. In the beginning, I was kind of a lurker too.

IbogaProject

(4,453 posts)
15. My Grandfather served in WW1
Mon May 26, 2025, 03:49 PM
Monday

He took Memorial Day very seriously in remembrance of his fallen fellow members of his time in Europe.

senseandsensibility

(22,217 posts)
17. I think having the experience of relatives who fought in WW1 or
Mon May 26, 2025, 04:24 PM
Monday

WWII is really helpful in understanding what we are fighting against today. My late father in law served in combat in WWII as a teenager and then two tours in Vietnam. He never bragged, but he knew what he and his comrades had fought for.

Ol Janx Spirit

(239 posts)
18. American progressives and conservatives alike stand under the umbrella of
Mon May 26, 2025, 04:27 PM
Monday

freedom created by those that fought to ensure it for everyone.

As polarized as we are, we are all lucky that we can have these disagreements standing under the flag of our independent nation formed by the Constitution. History could easily see us standing under a British flag, a Confederate flag, a German flag, or a Japanese flag. Honoring that should be among the least political things we do as Americans. Sadly, that is not the case.

Thank you for your post.

TnDem

(853 posts)
20. Google disagrees
Mon May 26, 2025, 04:29 PM
Monday

They always have a banner with the multicultural flavor of the day tagging their homepage logo.

Today it is gray with no wording.

senseandsensibility

(22,217 posts)
25. You're right
Mon May 26, 2025, 04:47 PM
Monday

However, and this is just my opinion, it seems like some Dems are squeamish about proclaiming their patriotism. And they shouldn't be, because it kind of gives the issue to R's.

LoisB

(10,594 posts)
26. You are absolutely correct. I never understood how they got to define themselves as the
Mon May 26, 2025, 04:49 PM
Monday

"true" patriots.

Eko

(9,253 posts)
27. I can understand that as the right has been trying to say they are the patriots for a long time.
Mon May 26, 2025, 05:00 PM
Monday

But one of my ancestors was one of those radicals that fought against having a king and said some things that helped change our nation so I'll be dammed if they get to take it from us.

Skittles

(164,484 posts)
34. YOU GOT THAT RIGHT
Tue May 27, 2025, 02:28 AM
Tuesday

I cannot see in ANY way how repukes are truly patriotic - NONE AT ALL

magicarpet

(18,333 posts)
30. The teDUMP brand of patriotism is nauseating.
Mon May 26, 2025, 07:56 PM
Monday

The ones who act like Fascists - but are sure to march around with a Chinese made AmeriKKKan flag on their left lapel to "prove" their patriotic bona fides.

Same goes with the sisters and brothers comprised of Christo-Fascists claiming to prove their Christian Nationalism bona fides with a fake golden cross of Jesus - likely again made in China. But they are so proud to march around and display to the public that they are Born Again devout followers of Jesus.

But if they bumped into Jesus while he was giving one of his sermons,... they would run off and gather a mob of their violence prone friends. Returning to the reveal tent where Jesus spoke. Then drag him outside and stone him until dead for condoning inclusivity, diversity, and human kindness.

It gets to the point where uttering the Pledge of Alleigence is a mind shameful and boggling endeavor. This is where we proclaim freedom and justice for all. But we have no fucking intentions to honor that commitment.

A country where liars and cheats like djt, Fux Snuz, dearly departed Rush Limbaugh amongst many many othersè are permitted to hide behind the First Ammendment of Free Speech Rights. While they incessantly dish out right-wing propaganda which is distorting and fabricating reality and tearing our country apart. But they get a pass from our government and our courts to crank out more propaganda while being waved on by because Freedom of Speech permits and encourages them to do so and there is nothing that can be done about it.

Then when half the population refuses to vote and becomes hyper cynical - we can find no rhyme or reason for this degree of voter apathy. As our system of Democratic governance swirls around the drain of Fascism, until there is no Democracy left any more. We had it -but we lost it - because we were to tangled up in institutionalized protocols, congressional decorum, and respect for our brothers and sisters on the opposite side of the aisle - while they savagely ripped the carpet of Democracy right out from under us. While they parked the USA in the cesspool of dictators despots, and authoritarianism. As the billionaires and oligarchs proceed to divide anything of value remaining in America among themselves.

Everyone else can just go take a hike.

The laws of diminishing confidence.
The only thing that lies ahead for us, our children, and our

grand-children is a much bleaker tomorrow. We must put a halt to this cascading rampage of greed and gluttony by the richer class.




WarGamer

(17,149 posts)
31. Call it the cynic in me...
Mon May 26, 2025, 08:20 PM
Monday

But how many NEEDED to go fight and die?

~400k died in defense of Europe...

Easy to think of WW2 as an opportunity for the US to "save" Europe...

Also easy to see the opportunity for American Hegemony post WW2

Martin Eden

(14,380 posts)
35. We honor those who sacrificed, even needlessly
Tue May 27, 2025, 06:42 AM
Tuesday

Last edited Tue May 27, 2025, 06:36 PM - Edit history (1)

GW's illegal and counterproductive war in Iraq did nothing to protect our freedoms. If anything, it created a recruiting and training ground for the next generation of terrorists.

Nevertheless, it is altogether fitting that we honor our soldiers who gave their all in that conflict. They went where their country sent them.

WarGamer

(17,149 posts)
36. I'm quite the cynic...
Tue May 27, 2025, 04:30 PM
Tuesday

IMHO... the US didn't stage D-Day to defeat the Nazis.

By June of 1944, The German military had been decimated on the Eastern front.

The Battle of Moscow, the Winter offensive... Kharkov, Stalingrad, Kursk...

By D-Day the German Eastern front had collapsed.

Millions of fatalities.

They'd lost control over the air and seas...



The US didn't need to invade France to defeat Germany.

The Russians would have done it... later in 1945.

But FDR and Churchill agreed to D-Day for the SOLE PURPOSE of preventing the USSR from driving WEST after Berlin and raising the red flag over all of Europe.

So in reality... Grandpa JJ didn't die to stop the Nazis, he died to stop the Communists.

Martin Eden

(14,380 posts)
37. From D-Day to VE day was 10+ months
Tue May 27, 2025, 06:57 PM
Tuesday

During that time the German army fought tenaciously on two fronts. Defeating the Nazi regime required great effort east & west.

The Russians wanted the Western allies to invade Europe in 1943, and were not happy when we decided to attack the Germans in Africa then up through Sicily & Italy.

A case can be made that holding back on invading Western Europe worked against Russian interests, allowing Germany to throw more resources at the Eastern front.

Long term geostrategic advantages are of course taken into consideration. Stalin was a monster to rival Hitler. We also had a major war to fight in the Pacific theater.

A degree of skepticism if not cynicism is called for, because the real motives behind wars are not necessarily for public consumption. Smedley Butler called the wars of the late 19th and early 20th century a "racket" fought to enrich corporations.

None of which means we should not honor the soldiers who sacrificed so much.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»This is probably my most ...