Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
59 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Senator Ron Johnson, a Republican, just announced he plans to kill Donald Trump's big beautiful bill. (Original Post) Swede Saturday OP
Why? Isn't it fascist enough for him? Ocelot II Saturday #1
Seriously, I think you nailed it. He probably wants to get rid of Medicaid completely, remove the increase JohnSJ Saturday #8
I remember what a shock it was PatSeg Saturday #40
Yes. Like Massie in the House, his objection isn't that the tax cuts are increasing the deficit too much Wiz Imp Saturday #33
Pishaw! Bayard Saturday #2
Call his office and tell him to defeat of this cruel and sadistic bill vapor2 Saturday #3
If someone does that, he will do just the opposite. Johnson is a very cruel person. The only reason he would JohnSJ Saturday #5
Sure, they will talk tough for a while and then they'll cave in Walleye Saturday #4
He's after something for himself radical noodle Saturday #6
Ron Johnson thinks it doesn't hurt average Americans enough, and it doesn't benefit the wealthy enough. sop Saturday #7
He won't vote for it 'in its current form' peggysue2 Saturday #9
Absolutely, and no one should be surprised if he suceeds. JohnSJ Saturday #11
Plus some pet projects for his state. underpants Saturday #14
Anyone who thinks this is good news is only deluding themselves. It will even make a more deplorable bill JohnSJ Saturday #10
Ronald has to decide if fealty to trump is more important than his career as an elected official. Snarkoleptic Saturday #12
WRONG. His objection is the bill doesn't cut spending enough. In other words, it needs to be MORE cruel. Wiz Imp Saturday #56
Are there many Medicaid recipients in WI? Or do they not vote? All the Ron Johnsons should allegorical oracle Saturday #59
So he's pulling a Manchin. C_U_L8R Saturday #13
Sure Jan.. .. Lovie777 Saturday #15
Did ronnie grow a spine? spanone Saturday #16
He might just be angling for something in his own self-interest. ananda Saturday #17
Spoiler alert: He will vote for it in the current form Prairie Gates Saturday #18
Wanna Bet? No way he does. Wiz Imp Saturday #38
Bullshit. He'll cave like they all do - always. hatrack Saturday #19
WRONG. He will NOT vote for the bill unless it cuts more spending. Wiz Imp Saturday #41
"He won't vote for it 'in its current form'" J_William_Ryan Saturday #20
It is even possible the whole thing was destined to fail, valleyrogue Saturday #21
Totally disagree gab13by13 Saturday #24
I'm not sure you understand. Johnson wants to kill many MORE millions to benefit billionaires. Wiz Imp Saturday #42
Just like they would never actually kill Roe? NYC Liberal Saturday #58
If Collins and Tillis join Johnson, that's a wrap. Fiendish Thingy Saturday #22
They will pass a bill, unfortunately I think it will even be more deplorable than the one the House did. JohnSJ Saturday #26
I don't Fiendish Thingy Saturday #29
I hope you are right Fiendish. The House bill as it is, is a disaster where a lot of people will get hurt, and JohnSJ Saturday #39
Enough with this garbage Fetterman would not vote for this bill in a million years. Wiz Imp Saturday #43
All it takes is a phone call from Trump dalton99a Saturday #23
Bingo. gab13by13 Saturday #25
Zero chance he holds to this or Eliot Rosewater Saturday #27
He absolutely will stick with this. He is demanding MORE cuts to spending and he's not backing down. Wiz Imp Saturday #44
Just give him a little more cowbell on the cruelty side and he'll be fine BeyondGeography Saturday #28
It probably doesn't give enough money to Russia Renew Deal Saturday #30
Yeah, he's gonna kill it. Right up until he gets his call from Trump. rsdsharp Saturday #31
Nope. He's demanding MORE spending cuts and he's not backing down. Wiz Imp Saturday #45
When Trump tells him to jump, he'll ask "how high" on the way up. rsdsharp Saturday #49
Nope. He's not gonna back down. Wiz Imp Saturday #53
A Republican with a spine? Sogo Saturday #32
It's not spine. He want's significantly MORE spending cuts Wiz Imp Saturday #46
Words are one thing, actions are another sakabatou Saturday #34
This made me laugh out loud JoseBalow Saturday #35
Sorry. He's not gonna back down. Only he can't kill it on his own. Wiz Imp Saturday #47
LOL! JoseBalow Saturday #51
Ssomething changed with him Figarosmom Saturday #36
He effectively wants ALL government spending zeroed out. The tax cuts for billionaires are A-OK Wiz Imp Saturday #50
In other words, he is looking for bribes. Emile Saturday #37
Yes a big beautiful bribe cutroot Saturday #55
He's moving in with Putin. milestogo Saturday #48
I heard him badmouthing the bill about a month ago on FAUX senseandsensibility Saturday #52
Completely FAKE headline. Wiz Imp Saturday #54
It will take Chip Roy level cruelty & selfishness for him to vote for it. nt Hotler Saturday #57

Ocelot II

(124,863 posts)
1. Why? Isn't it fascist enough for him?
Sat May 24, 2025, 11:14 AM
Saturday

But Ron is the second-stupidest member of the Senate (narrowly edged out by Tuberville), so who knows where he's going...

JohnSJ

(98,746 posts)
8. Seriously, I think you nailed it. He probably wants to get rid of Medicaid completely, remove the increase
Sat May 24, 2025, 11:32 AM
Saturday

in the SALT deduction, and get rid of more programs that help the working poor.

You can be that it isn't to remove the tax breaks for the wealthy.

He is one of the most diabolical sadists in the Senate. Not a good person at all.

Shame on Wisconsin for electing him, and for throwing out Russ Feingold many years ago.



PatSeg

(50,239 posts)
40. I remember what a shock it was
Sat May 24, 2025, 01:44 PM
Saturday

when he beat Russ Feingold, one our best senators. So disappointing.

Wiz Imp

(5,141 posts)
33. Yes. Like Massie in the House, his objection isn't that the tax cuts are increasing the deficit too much
Sat May 24, 2025, 01:37 PM
Saturday

It's that he thinks absolutely EVERYTHING else should be cut to reduce the deficit, while maintaining the tax cuts.

Bayard

(25,217 posts)
2. Pishaw!
Sat May 24, 2025, 11:16 AM
Saturday

They'll tweak a few things and he'll knuckle under like the rest, while telling his constituents that, he tried.

JohnSJ

(98,746 posts)
5. If someone does that, he will do just the opposite. Johnson is a very cruel person. The only reason he would
Sat May 24, 2025, 11:27 AM
Saturday

be opposing it is because it doesn't hurt enough people.

He probably want all poor not to receive any medicaid.

Walleye

(40,632 posts)
4. Sure, they will talk tough for a while and then they'll cave in
Sat May 24, 2025, 11:26 AM
Saturday

I remember Trump’s call to the Georgia Secretary of State after the 2020 election. We heard part of it but it actually went on for an hour. Can you imagine having that in your ear, you’d say yes just to shut him up. I was reading that the recalcitrant legislator gets taken into their cloakroom and given a cell phone with Trump yelling on the other end and that’s how they get them on their side. They are all cowards

sop

(14,373 posts)
7. Ron Johnson thinks it doesn't hurt average Americans enough, and it doesn't benefit the wealthy enough.
Sat May 24, 2025, 11:32 AM
Saturday

I'd like to see a few Republicans come out and say they won't support the bill because it hurts average Americans too much, and benefits the wealthy far too much.

peggysue2

(11,869 posts)
9. He won't vote for it 'in its current form'
Sat May 24, 2025, 11:33 AM
Saturday

Which means he'll be willing to cut social programs and safety nets down to nothing.

Because tax cuts for the filthy rich.

underpants

(190,791 posts)
14. Plus some pet projects for his state.
Sat May 24, 2025, 12:09 PM
Saturday

But hey, that’s how politics/governance usually works.

JohnSJ

(98,746 posts)
10. Anyone who thinks this is good news is only deluding themselves. It will even make a more deplorable bill
Sat May 24, 2025, 11:34 AM
Saturday

worse.


Snarkoleptic

(6,131 posts)
12. Ronald has to decide if fealty to trump is more important than his career as an elected official.
Sat May 24, 2025, 11:35 AM
Saturday
https://www.kff.org/interactive/medicaid-state-fact-sheets/

1,278,000 children and adults are enrolled in Wisconsin Medicaid, which will be crushed.

Wiz Imp

(5,141 posts)
56. WRONG. His objection is the bill doesn't cut spending enough. In other words, it needs to be MORE cruel.
Sat May 24, 2025, 02:17 PM
Saturday

That kind of attitude seems to be admired by the MAGA base. And he can stick to his principles and vote against any bill that doesn't cut enough, without killing it by himself which I expect him to do. Remember, they need 4 no votes to kill it so Johnson by himself is not going to be considered a huge problem by the rest of the Republicans.

allegorical oracle

(4,984 posts)
59. Are there many Medicaid recipients in WI? Or do they not vote? All the Ron Johnsons should
Sat May 24, 2025, 03:15 PM
Saturday

be cornered -- djt on one side versus angry, vocal voters who make sure they lose their next election.

Wiz Imp

(5,141 posts)
38. Wanna Bet? No way he does.
Sat May 24, 2025, 01:42 PM
Saturday

He will NOT vote for the bill unless more government spending is cut. Guaranteed.

J_William_Ryan

(2,754 posts)
20. "He won't vote for it 'in its current form'"
Sat May 24, 2025, 12:35 PM
Saturday

Correct.

It’s naïve to believe that Republicans will save Medicare and Medicaid.

valleyrogue

(2,100 posts)
21. It is even possible the whole thing was destined to fail,
Sat May 24, 2025, 12:39 PM
Saturday

with the House nutjobs passing it knowing the Senate would kill it in its tracks. The Senate can easily kill legislation with one person objecting, especially if that one person is from the same party as the president.

I don't think there is any way in hell these people are going to actually kill millions of people to benefit a handful of billionaires. The political fallout would be a disaster.

Granted, they are an evil bunch, but they aren't about to destroy the American medical industry with insane legislation to sharply cut Medicaid and Medicare. Those over 65 are the biggest beneficiaries of both programs, and they are also the most reliable voting bloc.

gab13by13

(28,248 posts)
24. Totally disagree
Sat May 24, 2025, 12:49 PM
Saturday

Republicans have been trying to gut the social safety net for decades.

This is the beginning of the end for those programs.

Wiz Imp

(5,141 posts)
42. I'm not sure you understand. Johnson wants to kill many MORE millions to benefit billionaires.
Sat May 24, 2025, 01:45 PM
Saturday

That is his objection.

Fiendish Thingy

(19,360 posts)
22. If Collins and Tillis join Johnson, that's a wrap.
Sat May 24, 2025, 12:49 PM
Saturday

Assuming Fetterman doesn’t cross the aisle.

I think they will pass a bill, but the most heinous parts will be diluted in order to get enough senators to vote yes.

JohnSJ

(98,746 posts)
26. They will pass a bill, unfortunately I think it will even be more deplorable than the one the House did.
Sat May 24, 2025, 12:53 PM
Saturday

Fiendish Thingy

(19,360 posts)
29. I don't
Sat May 24, 2025, 01:07 PM
Saturday

Collins and Tillis are very vulnerable in 2026, and even Josh Hawley has come out strongly against the Medicaid cuts.

There will still be some shitty stuff in the final bill, but it won’t be worse than the one the house passed- they want to keep the senate in the midterms so they can keep confirming Trump judges.

JohnSJ

(98,746 posts)
39. I hope you are right Fiendish. The House bill as it is, is a disaster where a lot of people will get hurt, and
Sat May 24, 2025, 01:42 PM
Saturday

supposedly there were House republicans in vulnerable districts who still voted for it.


Wiz Imp

(5,141 posts)
43. Enough with this garbage Fetterman would not vote for this bill in a million years.
Sat May 24, 2025, 01:49 PM
Saturday

Collins and Murkowski object to it for completely different reasons than Johnson and Rand Paul andd then osh Hawley is out there with his own objections.

They'll eventually come up with something that will get the 50 votes they need, but we don't know what that will look like or if the House will then pass the Senate's version.

Eliot Rosewater

(32,886 posts)
27. Zero chance he holds to this or
Sat May 24, 2025, 12:54 PM
Saturday

Or What he actually opposes is not the cuts that will kill people.

The piece of shit in the White House and maga wanna kill all of us, do people understand that now?

When I think of how many people pushed back at me when I said that two years ago, six years ago

Wiz Imp

(5,141 posts)
44. He absolutely will stick with this. He is demanding MORE cuts to spending and he's not backing down.
Sat May 24, 2025, 01:50 PM
Saturday

rsdsharp

(10,830 posts)
31. Yeah, he's gonna kill it. Right up until he gets his call from Trump.
Sat May 24, 2025, 01:15 PM
Saturday

Then he’ll fall on his knees, and search for Dear Leader’s tiny little mushroom.🍄

Wiz Imp

(5,141 posts)
45. Nope. He's demanding MORE spending cuts and he's not backing down.
Sat May 24, 2025, 01:54 PM
Saturday

But he can't kill it on his own. As long as no more than 3 people vote NO, it will pass. But there are enough people with various conflicting issues with the House bill, that there will be major changes to it before they vote on it in the Senate.

Wiz Imp

(5,141 posts)
53. Nope. He's not gonna back down.
Sat May 24, 2025, 02:03 PM
Saturday

He can't kill the bill on his own so he can stick to his "principles" which I'm sure he will. They can afford up to 3 NO votes and still pass it. And the reason for those NO votes don't all have to be the same. They'll eventually come up with something that gets the 50 votes they need, but Johnson won't be one of those unless significant additional spending cuts are included.

Sogo

(6,256 posts)
32. A Republican with a spine?
Sat May 24, 2025, 01:24 PM
Saturday

....although he did leave himself an out by adding "in its current form."

Figarosmom

(5,866 posts)
36. Ssomething changed with him
Sat May 24, 2025, 01:39 PM
Saturday

I wonder if trump went too far in his threats to him and his family. He's been sounding like he absolutely hates trump now. He used to carry water for him , completely in. But lately not so much.

Wiz Imp

(5,141 posts)
50. He effectively wants ALL government spending zeroed out. The tax cuts for billionaires are A-OK
Sat May 24, 2025, 01:58 PM
Saturday

but he's not OK with the increasing deficit.

He's actually one of the few being honest about the deficit, but his solution is to cut EVERYTHINg - SOCIAL SECURITY, MEDICARE, MEDICAID - if h had his way he'd completely get rid of all of them.

senseandsensibility

(22,189 posts)
52. I heard him badmouthing the bill about a month ago on FAUX
Sat May 24, 2025, 02:00 PM
Saturday

saying it should be broken into smaller bills and that it would not pass the Senate, at least until the end of the year. That said, I'll believe it when I see it.

Wiz Imp

(5,141 posts)
54. Completely FAKE headline.
Sat May 24, 2025, 02:09 PM
Saturday

He didn't say he was gonna kill the bill. He said he wouldn't vote for it. He can't kill it on his own. He needs 3 others to vote NO too to kill it. He will only vote for it if they include significantly more spending cuts which they may rewrite it to do, but that may jeopardize other votes. I'm sure they'll com up with something that will get the 50 votes they need, but it will be significantly different than the house version. And I'm betting the final Senate approved version will not include enough cuts to get Johnson to vote for it (but they don't need his vote).

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Senator Ron Johnson, a Re...